Don’t Accept a Denial: How to Appeal Your Personal Injury Claim

by | Jan 17, 2025

Getting your personal injury claim denied can feel like a dead end, but it doesn’t have to be. Whether it’s a slip-and-fall claim denied or an issue with your car insurance, there are ways to push back and fight for the compensation you deserve.

The process might seem overwhelming, but this guide will explain what to do when car insurance denies the claim or when insurance refuses to pay a claim for any personal injury you’ve suffered.

Keep reading to learn how to successfully appeal an insurance denial and take the first step toward turning this challenging situation around.

Why Was Your Personal Injury Claim Denied?  

Before appealing, it’s important to understand why insurance denied your claim in the first place. Insurers might deny claims for several reasons. Sometimes, it’s about missing paperwork or incorrect filing.

Other times, they argue your injuries aren’t as severe as claimed or that someone else was at fault. However, a denial doesn’t mean the end. It’s simply the beginning of the next step in the personal injury process.  

Steps to Take After Receiving a Denial  

Getting denied isn’t the final chapter. Here are some steps toward a successful appeal.  

Review the Denial Letter  

The first thing you should do is carefully review the denial letter sent by the insurance company. This document outlines why your insurance refuses to pay the claim. Pay attention to the reasons listed, as they’ll help you understand the insurer’s argument.

Collect Additional Evidence  

Sometimes, a claim is denied because the evidence wasn’t strong enough. Gather everything you can to prove your case. Medical records, photos of injuries, accident reports, and witness statements can all strengthen your argument.

For example, if your slip and fall claim was denied, consider obtaining camera footage or more detailed testimonies from witnesses. Every detail matters.  

Write a Strong Appeal Letter  

Now, it’s time to explain your side through an appeal letter. Be clear, professional, and factual. Reference the reasons for denial and provide the additional evidence you’ve collected to refute those points. This is a key step in how to successfully appeal an insurance denial.

Filing an appeal isn’t easy, especially if this is your first go-round with an insurance company. If unsure about your next steps, consider hiring a legal professional. Working with experts, like a Tulsa accident lawyer, can make a big difference in your case.

They’ll understand how to handle tricky situations, whether appealing a pain and suffering insurance claim or proving a bad faith claim against the insurer.  

How Long Does the Appeals Process Take?  

Unfortunately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. The time depends on the complexity of your case and the insurance provider’s responsiveness. Some appeals can take weeks, while others stretch into months.

How an Attorney Can Help Strengthen Your Appeal  

You may wonder, do you need a lawyer after a car accident? or for other denied claims. While you can technically appeal on your own, having an attorney increases your chances of success.

Lawyers specialize in navigating the system, gathering evidence, and making persuasive arguments. They’ll also hold insurers accountable if they act unfairly, protecting you from further mistreatment.

Don’t Give Up—Take Action Now  

Appealing a denied insurance claim may feel overwhelming, but it’s a battle worth fighting. Whether you’re facing a slip-and-fall claim denied or wondering what to do when car insurance denies the claim, these steps can help you take control of the situation.  

If you’re still unsure where to start or feel stuck, Anderson & Associates is here to help. Contact us for support and guidance with your appeal.

Lynn R. Anderson

Lynn R. Anderson

Lynn R. Anderson, a senior attorney at Anderson & Associates Law Firm, specializes in personal injury, estate planning, and business law. With over 30 years of experience, he is known for his personal touch and effective negotiation skills. A Tulsa native, Lynn enjoys photography and blogging about current events. He is married with two children and four dogs.